Sean O'Hagan has a gift for orchestral pop, creating lush soundscapes that are awash with sonic detail. He clearly owes a lot to
Brian Wilson, and
Hawaii,
the High Llamas' third album, falls somewhere between
Pet Sounds and
SMiLE. Sonically, the rich, orchestrated production is reminiscent of the former, but
Hawaii is paced like
SMiLE, with brief instrumentals and song fragments framing the full-fledged songs. Each is carefully arranged and recorded, offering an inviting tapestry of strings, guitars, keyboards, brass, and percussion. For much of
Hawaii, the sound of the record is intoxicating, but the album drags over the course of 77 minutes. Among the 29 tracks, there are some beautiful moments and gorgeous songs, but
Hawaii winds up being too much of a good thing, lacking the focus of
Gideon Gaye. [The American edition of
Hawaii contains a 40-minute, six-track bonus disc, containing material previously unreleased in the U.S., including the B-sides for the
Nomads single.]
–
Stephen Thomas Erlewine, Rovi