This quintet led by drummer
Mel Lewis was actually part of his larger orchestra, so they were high gear by the time of this 1981 recording session. Pianist
Jim McNeely contributed the adventurous post-bop "Blue Note" and the intricate "Giving Way," the latter track featuring trombonist
John Mosca and
Dick Oatts (on alto flute).
McNeely's creative treatments of two of
Bud Powell's works, "Audrey" and "John's Abbey," are masterful, while the sensitive interpretation of
Duke Ellington's lush ballad "Warm Valley" is actually based on transcriptions of a number of recordings of the piece by its composer, highlighted by
Oatts' impassioned alto sax. The only standard on the date is a very lyrical unrehearsed trio performance of "I'm Old Fashioned." Bassist
Marc Johnson, who proved his value as a part of
Bill Evans' final trio, complements each selection with some imaginatively chosen lines, and the leader's brushwork is first rate, as always. Originally a Gatemouth LP before being reissued on CD by Landmark (with the added bonus of an alternate take of "Blue Note") in 1995, this release has unfortunately lapsed from print following the subsequent sales of Landmark to the now inactive Muse and 32Jazz.
–
Ken Dryden, Rovi