The second volume of
Susan Tedeschi's best work in many ways turns out to be better than the first. The reason for this is simply that the compilers at Sheridan Square Records reached deeper into her early catalog for material. While both volumes come from the same recordings, the choices here seem to be less carefully picked and offer a more immediate and versatile view of the performer. Most of the material on
Episode Two comes from
Tedeschi's first and third albums for Tone Cool, 1998's
Just Won't Burn and 2002's
Wait for Me, respectively. There are also a pair of tracks from her
Live from Austin, TX disc issued in 2004. Perfect examples of this are in the compilation's first three cuts. The opening "Can't Leave You Alone," which is self-penned, and the third track, an excellent cover of
John Prine's "Angel from Montgomery," come from her debut. The former is a burning wail of a blues cut, and the latter -- while not as fine as
Bonnie Raitt's signature reading -- is different and emotive enough to be a truly moving version graced by her slide work, which sets it apart. "I Fell in Love," written by
Tom Hambridge, one of her bandmates from the period, is a roiling boogie-woogie blues with a killer vocal by
Tedeschi; the track crackles with a pumping piano line that invokes the influences of both
Professor Longhair and
Marcia Ball and a pair of electric guitars in the red zone.
Jason Crosby's "Hampmotized" has a funky
Headhunters-esque keyboard line and slippery guitar work that snakes around it. Again, it's
Tedeschi's voice that's the primary attraction, but the music cooks. Of the live tracks, "Voodoo Woman" is a cover of the
Koko Taylor classic that does the original proud, and "Lost Lover Blues" (written by
Don Robey) is a slow, B-3 and guitar-driven Chicago blues that brings out all the melancholy and moan in the grain of the singer's voice. In fact, the only major tune from her early records that isn't here is
Paul Pena's "Gonna Move," which
Tedeschi rescued from the obscurity file. But herein lies the rub. Given that there are two volumes of this "best-of" that encompass virtually every track from
Just Won't Burn and
Wait for Me, why not just license and reissue the albums themselves in a double pack? None of the Verve material is here and the
Live from Austin, TX volume is out there on its own, so this makes no aesthetic sense at all. Nonetheless, as an introduction, pick
Episode Two -- it has no meandering moments, just a solid scoop of
Tedeschi's musical magnetism and roadhouse grit.
–
Thom Jurek, Rovi